Should Students Have Assigned Seats?

Above: Courtesy of Jennifer Umland; Below: Photos Courtesy of Families

Students in Jenny Umland's class choose their own seats.

When students walk into Jenny Umland’s class, they don’t automatically go to the same seat they sat in the day before. In her classroom at Riverdale Heights Elementary School in Bettendorf, Iowa, students are allowed to sit wherever they want. Umland doesn’t assign seats. In fact, she has done away with most of the regular desks and uses beach chairs, standing desks, and rocking chairs instead.

Riverdale Heights is one of a growing number of schools that have ditched assigned seats. Many teachers say letting kids choose where to sit helps them learn how to make good choices. Some teachers point out that students are often more comfortable speaking up when they’re sitting near kids they like the most.

“If kids are happy and comfortable, they are more willing to learn,” says Umland. After 19 years of teaching, she tried non-assigned seating for the first time this year. She says she’ll never go back.

But not all teachers are ready to get rid of their seating charts. Some say having assigned seats helps students focus on their work, instead of where they’ll sit. Teachers also argue that it cuts down on distracting talk in the classroom because kids can’t choose to sit next to their friends.

Here’s what two of our readers think.

Letting students sit wherever they want can create chaos.

Assigned seating helps keep classrooms under control. Without specific seats to go to, students might argue over who gets to sit in the best spots. I would find it hard to work in that environment.

A more controlled classroom leads to better learning. A 2012 study by Montana State University found that high school students did better on tests when a teacher assigned their seats. 

Kevwe Emoghene, Texas

Students should be comfortable when they learn.

My teacher, Mrs. Umland, allows us to choose our own seats, and it’s great! 

I used to dread sitting in the same seat every day. Being allowed to sit wherever I want makes school more enjoyable. I can sit where I’m most comfortable.   

Plus, the setup in my class helps kids get along better. If two students want to sit in the same spot, they have to talk it out and compromise.

Zach Zuiderveen, Iowa

What does your class think?
Should students have assigned seats?
Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.
Should students have assigned seats?
Please select an answer to vote.
Should students have assigned seats?
0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.
Text-to-Speech